• Solan Sync
  • Posts
  • [Claude Sonnet 3.5 vs. GPT-4o]: Who Wins the AI Content Creation Battle?

[Claude Sonnet 3.5 vs. GPT-4o]: Who Wins the AI Content Creation Battle?

Discover the ultimate AI showdown between Claude Sonnet 3.5 and GPT-4o. See who excels in social media posts, blogging, YouTube scripts, and more with video demos included.

[Claude Sonnet 3.5 vs. GPT-4o]: Who Wins the AI Content Creation Battle?

Discover the ultimate AI showdown between Claude Sonnet 3.5 and GPT-4o. See who excels in social media posts, blogging, YouTube scripts, and more with video demos included.

In the ever-evolving landscape of artificial intelligence, two of the most advanced language models, Claude Sonnet 3.5 and GPT-4o, have been put to the test. This detailed comparison showcases their performance across various content creation tasks, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each. From social media posts to coding assistance, we have conducted thorough evaluations to determine the ultimate AI champion. Read on to discover the results, accompanied by video demonstrations.

Social Media Post Writing

Prompt Used:



Context: You are a Social Media Expert GPT, a seasoned digital marketer who helps professionals create engaging and viral content for LinkedIn and Twitter. You have deep insights into what makes content shareable and engaging on these platforms.

Goal: I want to create a post for LinkedIn and a Twitter thread that will go viral on this topic: [Add the topic here].

Requirements:
• LinkedIn Post:
 Objective: Position myself as a thought leader in my industry.
 Tone: Professional yet approachable.
 Content: A story or an insight from my professional experience that offers value to the readers.
• Twitter Thread:
 Objective: Engage followers and spark conversations.
 Tone: Informative and conversational.
 Content: Break down a complex topic into a series of easy-to-understand tweets.

Instructions:
• For the LinkedIn post, start with a captivating hook that draws readers in. Follow up with a personal story or professional insight. Conclude with a call-to-action (CTA) that encourages engagement, such as asking a question or inviting comments.
• For the Twitter thread, start with a compelling opening tweet. Use the subsequent tweets to provide valuable insights or steps related to the topic. Ensure each tweet is engaging and adds value. Conclude the thread with a tweet that prompts followers to share their thoughts or experiences.

Results:
- Winner: Claude Sonnet 3.5
- Loser: GPT-4o

Claude Sonnet 3.5 excelled in crafting engaging and shareable social media posts, outperforming GPT-4o, which fell short of the mark.

Blogging

Prompt Used:



Context: You are an SEO Specialist GPT, an expert in creating content that ranks highly on Google. You understand the importance of keywords, meta descriptions, and engaging content that adheres to SEO best practices.

Goal: I want to write an SEO-optimized blog post that ranks on Google for the keyword “[target keyword]”.

Requirements:
• Length: 1500–2000 words.
• Structure: Introduction, main body (divided into subheadings), conclusion.
• Keywords: Use the target keyword naturally throughout the post, including in the title, headings, and body text.
• Meta Description: Write a compelling meta description that includes the target keyword.
• Internal and External Links: Include relevant internal and external links to add value.

Instructions:
• Begin with a catchy introduction that includes the target keyword and hooks the reader.
• Divide the main body into clear sections with subheadings that incorporate the target keyword. Each section should provide valuable and well-researched information.
• Conclude with a summary and a call-to-action that encourages further engagement.
• Write a meta description of 150–160 characters that is enticing and includes the target keyword.
• Add internal links to related blog posts and external links to authoritative sources.

Results:
- Winner: GPT-4o
- Loser: Claude Sonnet 3.5

GPT-4o demonstrated superior capabilities in SEO-optimized blog writing, adhering closely to the prompt and delivering well-structured, keyword-rich content. Claude Sonnet 3.5, while competent, failed to fully meet the prompt’s requirements.

YouTube Scriptwriting

Prompt Used:


You are a Video Scriptwriter, an expert in creating engaging and informative scripts for YouTube. Your scripts are designed to capture the audience’s attention, keep them engaged, and encourage them to subscribe and share.

Goal: I want to create a script for a YouTube video that is over 5 minutes long, focused on [topic].

Requirements:
• Introduction: Hook the viewers in the first 30 seconds.
• Main Content: Provide valuable and engaging content.
• Engagement: Include prompts for likes, comments, and subscriptions.
• Conclusion: Summarize the content and provide a call-to-action.

Instructions:
• Start with a strong hook in the introduction to grab the viewer’s attention. Introduce the topic and briefly outline what will be covered.
• Develop the main content by breaking it down into sections. Each section should deliver valuable information, insights, or tutorials related to the topic.
• Throughout the video, include prompts that encourage viewers to like, comment, and subscribe.
• Conclude with a summary of the main points and a strong call-to-action, such as checking out another video or visiting your website for more information.

Results:
- Winner: GPT-4o
- Loser: Claude Sonnet 3.5

GPT-4o excelled in scriptwriting for YouTube, providing clear and engaging content with effective engagement prompts. Claude Sonnet 3.5, while capable, did not match the thoroughness and depth of GPT-4o’s script.

TikTok and Instagram Reels Creator

Prompt Used:


You are a Social Media Video Specialist, an expert in creating concise and engaging scripts for TikTok and Instagram Reels. Your scripts are designed to educate and entertain viewers within a short span of time.

Goal: I want to create a 1-minute script for an educational video on [topic] that can be used on TikTok and Instagram Reels.

Requirements:
• Introduction: Hook the viewer within the first few seconds.
• Main Content: Deliver educational content in a concise and engaging manner.
• Engagement: Include a prompt for likes, comments, and follows.

Instructions:
• Start with a quick, attention-grabbing hook to introduce the topic.
• Break down the main content into 2–3 key points that can be explained quickly and clearly.
• Conclude with a prompt that encourages viewers to like, comment, and follow for more content.

Results:
- Winner: Claude Sonnet 3.5
- Loser: GPT-4o

Claude Sonnet 3.5 outperformed GPT-4o in creating scripts for TikTok and Instagram Reels, delivering concise, engaging, and educational content that met all prompt requirements.

Coding Assistant to Build a Calculator

Prompt Used:



Context: You are a Coding Assistant, an expert in helping developers create and understand code. You provide clear, step-by-step instructions for coding projects.

Goal: I want to create a simple calculator using JavaScript.

Requirements:
• Functions: Addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.
• Interface: Basic HTML interface with buttons for numbers and operations.
• Display: Show the input and result on the screen.

Instructions:
• Create a basic HTML structure with a display area and buttons for numbers (0–9) and operations (+, -, *, /, =, C).
• Write JavaScript functions to handle each operation and update the display.
• Ensure the calculator handles edge cases, such as dividing by zero or pressing multiple operation buttons in a row.

Results:
- Winner: GPT-4o
- Loser: Claude Sonnet 3.5

GPT-4o provided clear, step-by-step instructions and well-organized code for building a JavaScript calculator. Claude Sonnet 3.5, although quick, did not focus adequately on the design and produced rough code suitable only for testing.

Conclusion

In this comprehensive showdown between Claude Sonnet 3.5 and GPT-4o, each model showcased its unique strengths and areas for improvement. 

While Claude Sonnet 3.5 excelled in social media posts and short-form video scripts, GPT-4o demonstrated superior performance in SEO blogging, YouTube scriptwriting, and coding assistance. The choice between these AI models ultimately depends on the specific content creation needs and preferences of the user.

Thank you for reading this article so far, you can also access ChatGPT tools and the AI-Powered Business Ideas Guides on my FREE newsletter.

What Will You Get?

  • Access to AI-Powered Business Ideas.

  • Access our News Letters to get help along your journey.

  • Access to our Upcoming Premium Tools for free.

🍎Chat GPT for Your Website in minutes

✅ Stop paying subscription. Try Awesome AI Tools & Prompts with the Best Deals

🧰 Find the Best AI Content Creation jobs

⭐️ ChatGPT materials

If you find this helpful, please consider buying me a cup of coffee.

Reply

or to participate.